Story: Did you know that Jason, Michael Meyers, Freddy Kreuger and all sortsa rampant killing machines actually exist?  Somebody should make a documentary about how one goes about becoming a serial killer!  Only one problem; you might get a bit too close….

Scares: Just when you think this is all gag and no gotcha, things ramp up nicely.

Splat factor: Even though it’s the story of  how a serial killer gets his start, there’s surprisingly little blood.  But don’t worry, the deaths are effective.  Very.

Closing scene “shocker”?: Not if you’ve been paying attention.  There’s a twist, and even though horror fans will know what that is, it’s a good time.

Remake, Sequel or OG (Original Ghoul)?: This is something I never thought I’d say; it’s a wholly original concept in the slasher genre.

Trick or Treat?: It’s definitely a treat, of the “new stuff you’re not sure you’ll like” variety.  The movie keeps you guessing throughout, with quite a few effective switcharoos in storyline and tone.  Is this guy batshit crazy? Or is he really a killer come back from the dead for vengeance…that happens to like turtles as pets? The documentary filmmakers tag along in the first half of the film, kinda like Mutual of Omaha’s Wild Kingdom. Of death.  The real horror is watching the “filmmakers” do nothing. It’s like they don’t believe /are too caught up in their own shoot. Things start gettin’ freaky towards the end, when the mockumentary style switches to straight-up storytelling.  Think something like that would kill the mood?  No way.  This is a great little film that deserves much more notice than it’s currently getting.  Gotta say I’ve had this in my queue for a while now, and only watched it for something to review.  I’m really glad I got around to it.  A smart, well-acted horror movie that is tongue-in-cheek, scary and has cameos by a few beloved masters of the genre is a beautiful thing indeed.

Score:  out of 5 pumpkins.